When we hear music we don't know, we may find it strange or even laugh in surprise. We all have preferences. But finding a sound unusual is not the same as making fun of the person who created it. I learned that distinction from a teacher at Tokyo University of the Arts. Another teacher showed me something just as important: what it means to receive someone else's work with genuine attention. Those two memories still support me when I share my own music.
I began studying music at twenty-three and eventually entered Tokyo University of the Arts, often attending classes in other departments, especially musicology. One professor I greatly admired taught me a great deal about music, including Bach's works. But what I remember most is his kindness.
During my seven years at the university, I hardly ever saw him lose his temper. Then, in one lecture, he played a recording that sounded unfamiliar, even rather strange, to us. A few students behind me started to laugh. Suddenly there was a loud bang: the professor had struck the desk.
He was deeply upset at the idea of laughing at music someone had made or condemning it without trying to understand it. I am recalling his message, not quoting a verbatim record of his words. The students apologized; he returned to his usual gentle manner, and the lecture continued.
I could understand why an unfamiliar recording might make someone laugh. That was precisely why his reaction affected me so deeply. Here was a man who almost never got angry, yet cared enough about another person's expression to speak up.
I don't take his lesson to mean that we must admire every composition or stop making thoughtful criticisms. We can disagree, question and assess work seriously. What troubles me is dismissing the person behind it with a laugh before making any effort to listen. I still catch myself being careless with criticism, but that day made me more aware of the difference.
I remember another professor at the university. A group of us students had gathered our own writings about music into a modest booklet to sell at the university arts festival. Looking back, the essays were probably quite rough.
We had not invited this professor to buy one. Yet he came as soon as sales began and bought a copy. He took an interest in something students had made and went out of his way to receive it. He wasn't promising that every page was excellent. The gesture itself mattered enormously to me.
Offering others something you have made because you truly wanted to make it can be frightening. You may believe in your own work and still have no idea how it will be received.
I think I have been able to share my music partly because I was fortunate enough to meet teachers and listeners who take people's work seriously. Not everybody will understand us, and not every piece will be loved. Yet it makes a difference to know that some people will listen with care.
One teacher taught me not to laugh away another person's music; the other showed me how much it matters to reach out and receive a small, tentative work. They gave me more than musical knowledge. They showed me the kind of listener I would like to become.
Read in other languages: 日本語 · Français · Deutsch · Español · Italiano · Português · Русский · 한국어 · 简体中文 · 繁體中文 · العربية · हिन्दी